The Huck Finn QUestion

The Huck Finn QUestion

Controversy and Conflict:   The Huck Finn Question
It was born into controversy in 1885 as Samuel Clemens published his
newest writing entitled The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.   It immediately
sparked debate and outrage that still continues to this day.   This book, some
critics contend, is a grotesque example of racist trash.   Citing numerous
examples, such as the treatment of minorities,   the objectionable language
displayed by the characters, and the unfair portrayal of Southerners, these critics
believe that this book is worthy of being banned from all schools.   Still, other critics
maintain that this novel is a true treasure of American literature that gives a
realistic portrayal of the times.   This same group of critics also argue that this
novel promotes racial unity and cooperation.   How could such   a novel give birth
to such contrasting viewpoints?   Are both arguments valid?   Should such a
controversial novel be taught in schools today?   This essay will examine both
arguements and point out each side’s logical points and flawed reasonings.
Afterwards, it will discuss whether or not this book should be taught in schools
today, the Huckleberry Finn question.
A large number of critics contend that the book Huckleberry Finn is racist
trash not fit for the classroom.   For example, John H. Wallace described the
assignment to read the book best when he said:
“..the assignment and reading aloud of Huckleberry Finn in our
classrooms is humiliating and insulting to black students... (Wallace, The
Case Against Huck Finn Pp. 17)”
This is a valid argument against the book Huckleberry Finn for many
reasons.   For example, Aunt Sally asks Huck about his trip after he arrives at her
house.   Huck goes on to describe an accident which occurred while on the boat in
which an African-American worker was killed.
In response to this story, Aunt Sally commented:
“Well, it’s lucky; because sometimes people do get hurt in these things.
(Twain,...